JD Vance UK Visit: Fishing, Free Speech, and the Special Relationship

JD Vance UK Visit: Fishing, Free Speech, and the Special Relationship

We haven’t seen much of Vice President JD Vance lately, but when we do, he’s usually making headlines for his political positions, not his vacation plans. This week was different. The JD Vance UK visit made headlines after he went fishing with British Foreign Secretary David Lammy. No, they didn’t catch a single fish, but they may have reeled in something more valuable: a reminder that diplomacy isn’t always about stiff suits and sterile conference rooms.

The UK press called it an unusual meeting. For Washington, it was downright unthinkable. A vice president trading the West Wing for waders? But that’s exactly what happened. And while the images might seem like political fluff, there’s more here than a feel-good photo op.

From Political Opposites to Fishing Buddies

Lammy and Vance could not be further apart on policy. Lammy is Labour through and through, a man who campaigned hard against Brexit, champions progressive causes, and leans heavily into the London political establishment. Vance is a Midwestern conservative who’s spent the last several years hammering away at globalism and the political class.

Yet here they were, side-by-side, laughing about the one strain on the special relationship that Vance’s kids caught trout while the grown-ups got skunked. The two first met back when Vance was a senator, and their unlikely friendship has apparently survived the climb up their respective political ladders.

Friendship, Foreign Policy, and the JD Vance UK Visit

In an era when most cross-party political relationships are performative at best, this one feels genuine. Maybe it’s the shared working-class roots, or maybe it’s the fact that both know what it’s like to grow up outside the cozy bubble of elite politics. Either way, it’s rare and worth noting.

Trump is set to go back to the UK in September to attend his second state dinner there at the invitation of King Charles.

But Starmer also indicated in July that the UK would move to recognize a Palestinian state in September if Israel doesn’t change its humanitarian treatment of Gaza — creating tension with the Trump administration, which has said it would not recognize Palestine.

“Obviously, the United Kingdom is going to make its decision. We have no plans to recognize a Palestinian state,” Vance said. “I don’t know what it would mean to really recognize a Palestinian state, given the lack of a functional government there.” – New York Post

Politics Never Fully Takes a Back Seat

Don’t think this was just about fishing and small talk. Vance and Lammy discussed the big topics of the day: Gaza, Ukraine, and the state of free speech. Vance reiterated the U.S. position against recognizing a Palestinian state under current conditions, making it clear that the Trump administration isn’t about to hand Hamas a diplomatic win.

He also raised concerns about what he sees as growing censorship in the UK, a warning that free societies erode when they start policing speech. It was a subtle but pointed reminder that while the special relationship runs deep, it’s not immune to the cultural battles playing out on both sides of the Atlantic.

JD Vance is phenomenal

Can he please stay? https://t.co/8vUifpRMMF

— Steven Barrett (@SBarrettBar) August 8, 2025

The UK’s Censorship Problem Is No Fish Tale — And It’s a Warning for Us

During the JD Vance UK visit, the Vice President warned Britain against speech-policing trends that could erode democratic freedoms.

Vance didn’t just talk about Gaza and Ukraine while standing in a trout stream—he also lobbed a warning at Britain about its slide into speech-policing. And he’s not wrong. The UK has turned hurt feelings into a police matter, and the receipts are piling up:

• Thousands arrested for “offensive” posts – In 2023 alone, UK police arrested over 12,000 people—roughly 33 a day—for messages deemed “grossly offensive” under vague laws like the Communications Act 2003. Most were dropped for lack of evidence, but not before lives were disrupted. Source

• Parents targeted – A mom was arrested after criticizing her child’s school in a private WhatsApp group. Apparently, even closed-door gripes are fair game now. Source

• Non-crime hate incidents – Between 2019 and 2024, police logged more than 250,000 “non-crime hate incidents”—reports that don’t result in charges but stay on record and can affect jobs. Source

• Jailed for a tweet – A nanny, Lucy Connolly, got over a year in prison for a single post advocating mass deportation. Whether you agree with her or not, that’s a sentence harsher than many violent offenders receive. Source

What the JD Vance UK Visit Warns America About

This is the dark path Vance was talking about, and it’s not some distant foreign problem. If you think U.S. officials wouldn’t love to import a system where police can knock on your door for a Facebook post about biology, think again. From the push to label dissent as “misinformation” to calls for criminalizing hate speech, America already has politicians eyeing Britain’s model like it’s the next shiny toy.

We’re already seeing shades of it here. As I wrote in Transgender Activism and Science: The Hostage Situation No One Wants to Talk About, even scientists at top universities feel forced to hide behind anonymity just to publish research that contradicts activist orthodoxy. When disagreement itself becomes dangerous, it’s only a matter of time before we’re living under the same kind of speech-policing Vance just warned about.

Vance’s riverbank warning wasn’t just for David Lammy. It was for us.

Soft Power from JD Vance’s UK Visit

The “Soft Power from JD Vance UK visit” moment showed diplomacy can happen outside the traditional halls of power.

Most Americans don’t pay attention to foreign trips unless they involve a major crisis or a viral gaffe. This visit wasn’t headline-grabbing for policy wonks, but it did something else: it made the Vice President look like a person, not just a talking head.

You can’t stage the kind of easy-going rapport that came through in those fishing photos. This wasn’t the standard grip-and-grin. It was family in tow, kids laughing, and a politician who looked like he actually wanted to be there.

A Break from the Usual Beltway Script

If you’ve noticed, Vance has been relatively quiet in the press lately. That’s not by accident. While the media hounds Trump’s every move, Vance has been carving out a different lane, one that relies more on building relationships and less on fueling the daily outrage machine.

This UK trip is a good example. It wasn’t about making splashy policy announcements. It was about reinforcing ties with one of America’s oldest allies in a way that felt human and unscripted. If it also gave the British press a chance to portray the Vice President as something other than Trump’s attack dog, all the better.

Why This Matters

The U.S.–UK “special relationship” has endured through major joint military conflicts—think World War II, the Gulf War, Afghanistan, and Iraq. What has held it together isn’t just treaties or press-conference optics. It’s the personal ties between leaders who can still pick up the phone—and talk—even when they sharply disagree.

JD Vance just gave us a real-time example. He stepped out of the Beltway spectacle, grabbed a fishing rod with the British Foreign Secretary, and still tackled heavy-duty issues—Gaza, Ukraine, and yes, a warning about free-speech erosion. That kind of informal diplomacy? It’s precisely what keeps alliances alive, even when everything else pushes them apart.

Final Cast

The JD Vance UK visit proved that even an informal fishing trip can shape foreign policy.

Whether you like his politics or not, JD Vance just reminded us that diplomacy isn’t dead — it’s just gone a little rustic. You can hash out foreign policy in a marble hall, or you can do it in waders with a fishing rod in hand. One option comes with better scenery and, if you’re lucky, lunch.

In this case, the trout got away. The photo op didn’t. And for the Vice President, that may be the bigger win.

Feature Image:Gage Skidmore from Surprise, AZ, United States of America, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons/edited in Canva Pro

The post JD Vance UK Visit: Fishing, Free Speech, and the Special Relationship appeared first on An Americanist.